Skip to main content

4 Van Halen songs that expose everything wrong with the Sammy Hagar era

Just...atrocious.
ByLee Vowell
Sammy Hagar performs
Sammy Hagar performs | Kevin Mazur/GettyImages

Van Halen was legendary, of course, but also one of the few hard rock bands that offered sustained excellence with different singers. There is a difference between what David Lee Roth could do and what Sammy Hagar tried to do.

Hagar had the purer voice, but who cares? This is rock & roll we are talking about. Voices only matter if a band wants to sell records while doing pop-adjacent fluff. Van Halen did that a bit with Hagar, more than Roth could have ever done.

But for pure, undiluted rock, the Roth years were better. If you wanted other songs that had poorly written lyrics and the drive to be commercially successful over artistic value, the Hagar era was the one you'd want.

4 terrible songs that show the Sammy Hagar era was not the best for Van Halen

"Aftershock"

Part of the problem here isn't Hagar, but the disjointedness of the song. It has all-the-feels acoustic and then scream singing that makes the iconic band attempt a more Skid Row vibe. There are maybe parts of good songs here, but they don't mesh well.

The lyrics are about something unfunny: Hagar's divorce. What might have been a good idea in theory became something where any emotion he felt was covered by the aggression of the music later in the song. Maybe he was angry and mad, but he sounds more like a hair-metal vocalist trying to prove he belongs.

"Amsterdam"

One aspect of Hagar that would never be confused with elite songwriters is his lyrics. He lacks in that department quite often, and has more corniness than true emotion. You don't necessarily feel empathy for what he is singing about, and you definitely won't with "Oh, wham bam/Oh, Amsterdam."

Sure, Eddie and Alex Van Halen liked the way Hagar's voice sounded, but just imagine how much better the band would have been had they had a singer who could write lyrics. This track is simply horrible.

"Crossing Over"

The idea of the song is a good one, though it is also sad. As the title implies, the tune is about death and grief.

The problem is that the song feels unfinished and like filler instead of a standalone song that people would want to listen to multiple times over. The shame is that the intent was valid, but the execution was not.

"Can't Stop Lovin' You"

Even the title of the song and how it is spelled strain credibility. It reads like something a 13-year-old might write in their first attempt to write a song. They will grow and develop in a way that Hagar didn't quite do.

The way the vocals are produced feels more like the Gin Blossoms than the great Van Halen. Perhaps Hagar just wanted to sound pristine and earnest. That's great rock & roll, right? (Hint: It's not.)

Add us as a preferred source on Google