Skip to main content

How The Lamb fallout opened the door for Phil Collins to front Genesis

A massive change...
ByStevieMac
2026 Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction Ceremony - Phil Collins
2026 Rock & Roll Hall Of Fame Induction Ceremony - Phil Collins | Frazer Harrison/GettyImages

As Phil Collins takes the stage again in an emotional Rock Hall of Fame induction, it’s a great time to reflect on two very significant albums early in his Genesis career. The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway from November 1974, and A Trick of the Tail from February 1976 gave Collins a fantastic, and somewhat unexpected, step up.

Without that, it’s questionable whether he would have had the amazing musical career he is now being honoured for. Or at least that’s how I see it anyway.

The story started earlier with Collins joining Genesis as drummer in 1971. He had three albums on his c.v. as Genesis drummer by the time it came to record The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway. He was well established as a band member, and the plaudits were rolling in for those albums.

Tensions led to a huge split in Genesis, and that Phil Collins' opportunity

A lot was expected for this next release, too. As often happens as a band progresses, the album marked a difficult point for Genesis. 

Peter Gabriel was busy working away on the story behind what became a double concept album. He did so alone, writing lyrics and weaving the whole narrative for the songs. In the meantime, the rest of the band were holed up elsewhere working on the music.

That started a series of separations between Gabriel and the others. Right through to recording with the band in Wales, Gabriel travelled from London; he was with his wife there after the difficult birth of his first child.

Things grew tense between Gabriel and the others. They were focused on the album and perhaps not as sympathetic to the singer's family worries at the time. That was the start of the end. Early in the album tour, Gabriel announced he would be leaving. Which, of course, created the opportunity for Collins to step up to the mic and the frontman slot. 

Collins played quite a part in the auditions for a replacement for Gabriel. He sang backup vocals as many other singers tried out for the role. While that search played out, the band were beginning to record their next album, A Trick of the Tail. With no fixed singer yet, Collins took the lead on “Squonk”, a track from the new album.

That led to him being selected, perhaps slightly reluctantly, but it all worked out superbly for him in the end. As that Hall of Fame induction illustrates.

It’s usually A Trick of the Tail that gets noted as a breakthrough moment for Collins, and rightly so. But if it hadn't been for the way the prior album developed and that fallout, maybe Gabriel would have remained for longer.

At a different time, an alternative replacement may have been found, and who knows what difference that would have made to Collin’s career. It’s all subjective, but every time I hear the Lamb album that’s where my mind turns to.

Add us as a preferred source on Google